| Name | Year | Pos. | Hometown / Previous School | |
| 2024 | ||||
| Second-Team | Sarah Veale | Sr. | OH | Fowler, Mich. / Fowler HS |
| Honorable Mention | Sage Schumacher | Sr. | MB | Mount Pleasant, Mich. / Beal City HS |
| 2023 | ||||
| Honorable Mention | Kelsey Vittitow | Jr. | L/DS | Bay City, Mich. / Valley Lutheran HS |
| 2022 | ||||
| Second-Team | Madison Thompson | So. | OH | Reese, Mich. / Reese HS |
| Honorable Mention | Peyton Gerstacker | Sr. | S | Midland, Mich. / Midland HS |
| 2021 | ||||
| Freshman of the Year | Sarah Veale | Fr. | OH | Fowler, Mich. / Fowler HS |
| Second-Team | Haley Clum | Sr. | MH | Grosse Ile, Mich. / Grosse Ile HS |
| Rylee Zimmer | So. | OH | Unionville, Mich. / Sebewaing HS | |
| Honorable Mention | Peyton Gerstacker | Jr. | S | Midland, Mich. / Midland HS |
| 2021 Spring | ||||
| Second-Team | Maria Vukaj | Jr. | OH | Davison, Mich. / Davison HS |
| Honorable Mention | Haley Clum | Sr. | MH | Grosse Ile, Mich. / Grosse Ile HS |
| 2019 | ||||
| Blocker of the Year | Emily Friesl | Jr. | MH | Byron Center, Mich. / Byron Center HS |
| First-Team | Emily Friesl | Jr. | MH | Byron Center, Mich. / Byron Center HS |
| Sarah Tabit | Sr. | OH | Mt. Morris, Mich. / EA Johnson HS | |
| Second-Team | Hannah Tabit | Sr. | S | Mt. Morris, Mich. / EA Johnson HS |
| Honorable Mention | Abbie Toland | Sr. | L/DS | Maumee, Ohio / Toledo Catholic HS |
| 2018 | ||||
| First-Team | Emily Friesl | So. | MH | Byron Center, Mich. / Byron Center HS |
| Sarah Tabit | Jr. | OH | Mt. Morris, Mich. / EA Johnson HS | |
| Honorable Mention | Abbie Toland | Jr. | L/DS | Maumee, Ohio / Toledo Catholic HS |
| 2017 | ||||
| Second-Team | McKenzie Schuster | Sr | RS | Columbus, Ohio / Dublin Scioto HS |
| Honorable Mention | Hannah Tabit | So | S | Mt. Morris, Mich. / EA Johnson HS |
| 2016 | ||||
| First-Team | Kaylee Schmitt | Sr. | MH | DeWitt, Mich. / DeWitt |
| Second-Team | Tamara Heller | Jr. | OH | Rome, Ohio / Ledgemont |
| Kelly Velucci | Sr. | S | Livonia, Mich. / Stevenson | |
| Honorable Mention | Emily Nieman | Jr. | L | Chesterfield, Mich. L'Anse Creuse North |
| 2015 | ||||
| Libero of the Year | Brooke Tiller | Sr. | Libero | Maumee, Ohio / Maumee |
| First-Team | Kaylee Schmitt | Jr. | MH | DeWitt, Mich. / DeWitt |
| Kelly Vellucci | Jr. | S | Livonia, Mich. / Stevenson | |
| Second-Team | Brooke Tiller | Sr. | Libero | Maumee, Ohio / Maumee |
| Honorable Mention | Andrea Brigham | Jr. | OH | Concord, Mich. / Concord HS |
| 2014 | ||||
| First-Team | Kelsey Ferla | Sr. | OH | Lincoln Park, Mich. / Gabriel Richard |
| Makenzie Frodle | Sr. | MH | Fraser, Mich. / Fraser | |
| Second-Team | Kelly Vellucci | So. | S | Livonia, Mich. / Stevenson |
| Honorable Mention | Kaylee Schmitt | So. | MH | Dewitt, Mich. / Dewitt |
| 2013 | ||||
| Second-Team | Kelsey Ferla | Jr. | OH |
Lincoln Park, Mich. / Gabriel Richard |
| Honorable Mention | Ashley Driscoll | Jr. | RS | Bellevue, Mich. / Pennfield |
| 2012 | ||||
| Second-Team | Sam Breault | Sr. | S | Bad Axe, Mich. / Bad Axe |
| Honorable Mention | Laurel Mattson | Sr. | Libero | Lake Odessa, Mich. / Lakewood |
| 2011 | ||||
| First-Team | Annie Buxton | Sr. | OH | Aurora, Ontario |
| Katie Fitzgerald | Sr. | MH | Whitby, Ont. / Sinclair SS | |
| Honorable Mention | Laura Ward | Sr. | Libero | White Lake, Mich. / Lakeland |
| 2010 | ||||
| First-Team | Annie Buxton | Sr. | OH | Aurora, Ontario |
| Second-Team | Katie Fitzgerald | Sr. | MH | Whitby, Ont. / Sinclair SS |
| Honorable Mention | Jessica Treiber | Sr. | OH | Sebewaing, Mich. / Unionville-Sebewaing |
| 2009 | ||||
| GLIAC Player of the Year | Kait Harris | Sr. | S | Essexville, Mich. / Garber |
| First-Team | Annie Buxton | Jr. | OH | Aurora, Ontario |
| Kait Harris | Sr. | S | Essexville, Mich. / Garber | |
| Second-Team | Jaclyn Carnago | Sr. | MH | St. Clair, Mich. |
| Jessica Treiber | Sr. | OH | Sebewaing, Mich. / Unionville-Sebewaing | |
| Honorable Mention | Allison Schlinkert | Sr. | OH | Marysville, Mich. |
| 2008 | ||||
| First-Team | Kait Harris | Jr. | S | Essexville, Mich. / Garber |
| Second-Team | Sarah Redoute | Sr. | OH | Clinton Twp., Mich. / L'Anse Creuse |
| Jaclyn Carnago | Jr. | MH | St. Clair, Mich. | |
| Honorable Mention | Carmen Schacher | Sr. | Libero | Flint, Mich. / Kearsley |
| 2007 | ||||
| Second-Team | Amy Howard | Sr. | S | Cass City, Mich. |
| Sarah Redoute | Jr. | OH | Clinton Twp., Mich. / L'Anse Creuse | |
| Honorable Mention | Carmen Schacher | Jr. | Libero | Flint, Mich. / Kearsley |
| 2006 | ||||
| Second-Team | Suzanne Beaver | Sr. | OH | Battle Creek, Mich. / Kellogg C.C. |
| Honorable Mention | Ashleigh Hubbard | Sr. | Libero | Battle Creek, Mich. / Kellogg C.C. |
| 1990 | ||||
| Second-Team | Chris Baird | So. | S | Saginaw, Mich. / Nouvel |
| 1987 | ||||
| Coach of the Year | Chris Bertie |