St. Joseph's, Indiana (8-1)
* - Wins Vacated
| Date | W/L | SV | SJ | Home/Away |
| Nov. 14 1998 | W | 97 | 84 | Home |
| Nov. 20 1999 | W | 98 | 80 | Away |
| Nov. 18 2000 | W | 79 | 56 | Away |
| Nov. 17 2001 | W-OT | 83 | 77 | Away |
| Nov. 11 2012 | W | 75 | 52 | Home |
| Nov. 10 2013 | W* | 74 | 72 | Away |
| Nov. 15 2014 | W* | 76 | 71 | Away |
| Nov. 15 2015 | L-2OT | 70 | 76 | Away |
| Nov. 13 2016 | W | 77 | 62 | Home |