| Name | Year | Pos. | Hometown/High School | |
| 2023-24 | ||||
| Second-Team | Aleshia Jones | Jr. | G | Leavenworth, Kan. / Iowa Western CC |
| Defensive-Team | Lydia Meredith | So. | G | Portland, Mich. / Portland St. Patrick's HS |
| 2022-23 | ||||
| Player of the Year | Kaitlyn Zarycki | Sr. | G | Niles, Mich. / Edwardsburg HS |
| First-Team | Kaitlyn Zarycki | Sr. | G | Niles, Mich. / Edwardsburg HS |
| Tori DePerry | Sr. | F | Shawano, Wis. / Shawano Community HS | |
| Defensive-Team | Saniaa Walker | Fr. | G | Flint, Mich. / Kearsley HS |
| 2021-22 | ||||
| First-Team | Kaitlyn Zarycki | Jr. | G | Niles, Mich. / Edwardsburg HS |
| Second-Team | Maddie Maloney | Sr. | G | St. Johns, Mich. / St. Johns HS |
| Defensive-Team | Kaitlyn Zarycki | Jr. | G | Niles, Mich. / Edwardsburg HS |
| 2020-21 | ||||
| First-Team | Kaitlyn Zarycki | So. | G | Niles, Mich. / Edwardsburg HS |
| Second-Team | Maddie Maloney | Jr. | G | St. Johns, Mich. / St. Johns HS |
| Defensive-Team | Kaitlyn Zarycki | So. | G | Niles, Mich. / Edwardsburg HS |
| 2019-20 | ||||
| Freshman of the Year | Kaitlyn Zarycki | Fr. | G | Niles, Mich. / Edwardsburg HS |
| Second-Team | Kaitlyn Zarycki | Fr. | G | Niles, Mich. / Edwardsburg HS |
| 2016-17 | ||||
| First-Team | Emily Wendling | Sr. | F | Flushing, Mich. / Flushing |
| Katelyn Carriere | Sr. | G | London, Ontario / John Paul II | |
| 2015-16 | ||||
| Player of the Year | Emily Wendling | Sr. | F | Flushing, Mich. / Flushing |
| Freshman of the Year | Halee Nieman | Fr. | F | Midland, Mich. / Bullock Creek |
| Second-Team | Katelyn Carriere | Jr. | G | London, Ontario / John Paul II |
| 2014-15 | ||||
| Second-Team | Emily Wendling | So. | F | Flushing, Mich. / Flushing |
| 2013-14 | ||||
| Second-Team | Kristen Greene | Sr. | G | Brown City, Mich. / Brown City |
| Kayla Womack | Sr. | G | Grosse Pointe Woods, Mich. / Grosse Pointe | |
| 2012-13 | ||||
| Freshman of the Year | Emily Wendling | Fr. | F | Flushing, Mich. / Flushing |
| First-Team | Emily Wendling | Fr. | F | Flushing, Mich. / Flushing |
| 2011-12 | ||||
| All-Defensive Team | Grace Herzog | Jr. | C | Linden, Mich. / Powers Catholic |
| 2007-08 | ||||
| North Second-Team | LaTille Ross | Sr. | F | Opelika, Ala. |
| 2004 | ||||
| North Second-Team | Jennifer Brogger | Sr. | G | Harbor Springs, Mich. |
| 2001 | ||||
| North Second-Team | Kathryn Williams | Jr. | G | Detroit, Mich. / Martin Luther King |
| 1997-98 | ||||
| First-Team All-GLIAC | Angie Peterson | So. | F | Ellsworth |
| Freshman of the Year | Karen Deurloo | Fr. | ||
| All-GLIAC Defense | Angie Peterson | So. | F | Ellsworth |
| 1995-96 | ||||
| Honorable Mention | Angie Peterson | Fr. | F | Ellsworth |
| Freshman of the Year | Angie Peterson | Fr. | F | Ellsworth |
| Academic All-GLIAC | Becky Jore | So. | C | Alpena |
| Becky Schramski | Fr. | C | Kingsley | |
| 1994-95 | ||||
| Second-Team All-GLIAC | Melanie Mosure | Jr. | G | Deckerville |
| All-GLIAC Defense | Melanie Mosure | Jr. | G | Deckerville |
| Academic All-GLIAC | Michelle Aerts | Sr. | F/G | West Bloomfield |
| Angela Birchmeier | Sr. | F/G | West Bloomfield | |
| 1993-94 | ||||
| First-Team All-GLIAC | Tracy Bruno | Sr. | F | St. Charles |
| Honorable Mention | Charlene Oesterling | Sr. | F | Tawas |
| All-GLIAC Defense | Tracy Bruno | Sr. | F | St. Charles |
| Academic All-GLIAC | Tracy Bruno | Sr. | F | St. Charles |
| Tracy Dohner | Sr. | G/F | Hemlock | |
| Alisa Niederstadt | Sr. | F | Saginaw/Valley Lutheran | |
| Angela Birchmeier | Jr. | F/G | West Bloomfield | |
| 1992-93 | ||||
| First-Team All-GLIAC | Roseann Rutledge |
Sr. |
G | Sand Creek |
| Second-Team All-GLIAC | Tracy Bruno | Jr. | F | St. Charles |
| Honorable Mention | Charlene Oesterling | Jr. | F | Tawas |
| All-GLIAC Defense First Team | Roseann Rutledge | Sr. | G | Sand Creek |
| Academic All-GLIAC First Team | Roseann Rutledge | Sr. | G | Sand Creek |
| Academic All-GLIAC Honorable Mention | Tracy Bruno | Jr. | F | St. Charles |
| 1990-91 | ||||
| Honorable Mention | Roseann Rutledge | So. | G | Sand Creek, Mich. / Sand Creek |
| 1989-90 | ||||
| First-Team All-GLIAC | Brenda Eiseler | Sr. | C | St. Johns |
| Honorable Mention | Rhonda Griffioen | Sr. | F | Wyoming/Grandville Calvin Christian |
| All-GLIAC Defensive | Rhonda Griffioen | Sr. | F | Wyoming/Grandville Calvin Christian |
| Academic All-GLIAC | Jessica Handley | Jr. | G | Canton, Mich. / Plymouth Salem |
| 1988-89 | ||||
| First-Team All-GLIAC | Brenda Eiseler | Jr. | C | St. Johns |
| Academic All-GLIAC | Brenda Eiseler | Jr. | C | St. Johns |
| Academic Honorable Mention | Jessica Handley | So. | G | Canton/Plymouth Salem |
| 1987-88 | ||||
| All-GLIAC First Team | Brenda Eiseler | So. | C | St. Johns |
| Lisa Home | So. | F | Flnt/Hamady | |
| Sue Mayes-Scott | Sr. | G | Saginaw/Carrollton | |
| Player of the Year | Sue Mayes-Scott | Sr. | G | Saginaw/Carrollton |
| All-GLIAC Defense | Sue Mayes-Scott | Sr. | G | Saginaw/Carrollton |
| Academic All-GLIAC Honorable Mention | Brenda Eiseler | So. | C | St. Johns |
| 1986-87 | ||||
| All-GLIAC First Team | Lisa Masters | Sr. | C | Detroit/Regina |
| Trena Sanders | So. | F | Benton Harbor | |
| Player of the Year | Lisa Masters | Sr. | C | Detroit/Regina |
| All-GLIAC Defensive | Lisa Masters | Sr. | C | Detroit/Regina |
| Sue Mayes-Scott | Jr. | G | Saginaw/Carrollton | |
| 1980-81 | ||||
| All-GLIAC | Diane Dockus | Sr. | C | Mt. Clemens, Mich. / L'Anse Creuse |
| 1979-80 | ||||
| All-GLIAC First Team | Diane Dockus | Jr. | C | Mt. Clemens, Mich. / L'Anse Creuse |
| Erika Bush | Jr. | F | North Branch, Mich. / North Branch |