All-American
| Year | Players | |
| 1980 | Steve Brady, Jim Quellman | (NAIA) |
| 1984 | Kendall Kinsey, Mike Mueller, Bob Stephens | (NAIA) |
| 1989 | Adam Anthony, Jay Kinsey | (NAIA) |
| 1998 | Brian Eggleston | (NCAA DII) |
| 2000 | Dave Tokarsky | (NCAA DII) |
Academic All-American
| Year | Players | |
| 1984 | Mike Mueller | (NAIA) |
| 1989 | Adam Anthony | (NAIA) |
| 1995 & 1996 | Tony Daggett | (NCAA DII) |
| 1999 & 2000 | Jason Gordon | (NCAA DII) |
| 2007 | Adam Miller | (NCAA DII) |
| 2008 | Sean Rutherford | (NCAA DII) |
| 2008 | Mike King | (NCAA DII) |
| 2010 | Dieter Schulz | (NCAA DII) |
| 2010 | Rob Ronk | (NCAA DII) |
| 2010 & 2011 | Nate Kelly | (NCAA DII) |
| 2014 & 2015 | Micah Skidmore | (NCAA DII) |
| 2017 & 2018 | Ryan Peruski | (NCAA DII) |
| 2018 | Dustin Pumford | (NCAA DII) |
| 2019 | Alex Dice, Jared Lyons, Dustin Pumford | (NCAA DII) |
| 2020 | Alex Dice, Jared Lyons, Mitch Hughes, Gunnar Stein | (NCAA DII) |
| 2022 | Jiseung Choi & Connor Jakacki | (NCAA DII) |