St. Joseph's College of Indiana (5-2)
* - Wins Vacated
| Date | W/L | SV | SJ | Home/Away |
| Dec. 6, 1980 | L | 68 | 81 | Away |
| Dec. 29, 2004 | L | 74 | 81 | Away |
| Nov. 17, 2007 | W | 88 | 65 | Home |
| Dec. 19, 2007 | W | 72 | 69 | Away |
| Nov. 14, 2014 | W* | 87 | 81 | Home |
| Nov. 14, 2015 | W* | 88 | 59 | Away |
| Nov. 12, 2016 | W* | 81 | 80 | Neutral |