Mercyhurst University (Pa.) (6-2)
| Date | W/L | SV | MU | Home/Away |
| October 31, 1998 |
W | 69 |
0 | Home |
| October 29, 1999 |
W | 40 |
33 | Away |
| October 7, 2000 |
W | 46 |
40 | Away |
| October 6, 2001 |
W | 28 |
21 |
Home |
| September 21, 2002 |
W |
51 |
7 |
Home |
| September 20, 2003 | W | 26 | 3 | Away |
| October 9, 2004 | L | 15 | 22 | Away |
| October 8, 2005 | L# | 44 | 14 | Home |
# - Forfeit