| Name | Year | Position | Hometown / Previous School | |
| 2023 | ||||
| First-Team | MzoMthembu | Jr. | F | Durban, South Africa / Varsity College |
| Donna Kheswa | Fr. | MF | Durban, South Africa / Durban Boys | |
| Felix Tom | Fr. | D | Margate, South Africa / Nombuso | |
| Honorable Mention | Alex Demorrow | So. | D | Allen Park, Mich. / Schoolcraft College |
| 2022 | ||||
| Offensive Player of the Year | Jonathan Monney | So. | F | |
| Defensive Player of the Year | Benjamin Adamson | So. | D | Hull, England / South Hunsley School |
| Coach of the Year | Louis Barrow | |||
| First-Team | Jonathan Monney | So. | F | |
| Benjamin Adamson | So. | D | Hull, England / South Hunsley School | |
| Robbie Baker | Sr. | D | Brisbane, Australia / St. Peters Lutheran College | |
| Jayden Cameron | Jr. | F | Brampton, Ontario / Sheridan College | |
| Second-Team | Brady Walker | Sr. | MF | Hartland, Mich. / Hartland |
| Nick Kay | Fr. | GK | Walled Lake, Mich. / Walled Lake Central | |
| Chidie Nnolim | Jr. | D | Brampton, Ontario / St. Marguerite D'Youville Secondary School | |
| Honorable Mention | Anthony Waller | So. | MF | Warren, Mich. / Cousino |
| 2021 | ||||
| First-Team | Robbie Bruce | Sr. | MF | Cullen, Scotland / LSU Shreveport |
| Benjamin Adamson | Fr. | D | Hull, England / South Hunsley School | |
| Second-Team | Robbie Baker | So. | MF | Brisbane, Australia / St. Peters Lutheran College |
| Brady Walker | Jr. | MF | Hartland, Mich. / Hartland HS | |
| Honorable Mention | Gabriello Calamita | Sr. | MF | Windsor, Ont. / Holy Names HS |
| 2021 Spring | ||||
| Offensive Player of the Year | Danny Barlow | Sr. | MF | Newcastle, England / University of Denver |
| Defensive Player of the Year | Robbie Baker | So. | MF | Brisbane, Australia / St. Peters Lutheran College |
| Goalkeeper of the Year | Mason Maziasz | Sr. | GK | Troy, Mich. / Troy Athens HS |
| Coach of the Year | Louis Barrow | |||
| First-Team | Danny Barlow | Sr. | MF | Newcastle, England / University of Denver |
| Robbie Bruce | Sr. | MF | Cullen, Scotland / LSU Shreveport | |
| Robbie Baker | So. | MF | Brisbane, Australia / St. Peters Lutheran College | |
| Mason Maziasz | Sr. | GK | Troy, Mich. / Troy Athens HS | |
| Second-Team | Kairo Coore | So. | F | Whitby, Ontario / Sinclair Secondary School |
| Brady Walker | Jr. | MF | Hartland, Mich. / Hartland HS | |
| Benjamin Adamson | So. | D | Hull, England / Sixth Form College | |
| Honorable Mention | Lachlan Hepburn | Jr. | D | Fenton, Mich. / Lake Fenton HS |
| 2019 | ||||
| Offensive Player of the Year | Connor Rutz | Sr. | MF | Commerce, Mich. / Schoolcraft College |
| First Team | Connor Rutz | Sr. | MF | Commerce, Mich. / Schoolcraft College |
| Second Team | Alex Gloshen | Jr. | MF | Traverse City, Mich. / Traverse City West HS |
| Wladimir Babaew | Sr. | D | Moscow, Russia / Northern Kentucky | |
| Honorable Mention | Robbie Bruce | Jr. | MF | Cullen, Scotland / LSU Shreveport |
| 2018 | ||||
| Defensive Player of the Year | Omar Sinclair | Sr. | D | Manchester, England / Bury College |
| Freshman of the Year | Lukas Betz | Fr. | GK | Frechen, Cologne, Germany / Albert-Schweitzer Gym |
| First Team | Omar Sinclair | Sr. | D | Manchester, England / Bury College |
| Azaad Liadi | Jr. | F | Sterling Heights, Mich. / Henry Ford II HS | |
| Michael Hamilton | So. | F | Madrid, Spain / Universidad Alcala de Henares | |
| Michael Shaikly | Sr. | MF | Colchester, England / University of Findlay | |
| Second Team | Lukas Betz | Fr. | GK | Crechen, Cologne, Germany / Albert-Schweitzer Gym |
| Honorable Mention | Wladimir Babaew | Jr. | D | Moscow, Russia / Northern Kentucky |
| 2017 | ||||
| Freshman of the Year | Michael Hamilton | Fr | F | Madrid, Spain / Alabama-Huntsville |
| Goalkeeper of the Year | Connor Keane | So | GK | Manchester, England / Loretta HS |
| First Team | Michael Hamilton | RFr | F | Madrid, Spain / Alabama-Huntsville |
| Matt Wilson | Sr | F | Huron Valley, Mich. / Oakland University | |
| Connor Keane | So | GK | Manchester, England / Loretta HS | |
| Dom Hart | Sr | D | Rotherham, England / Northwood University | |
| Omar Sinclair | Jr | D | Manchester, England / Bury College | |
| Connor Rutz | Jr | MF | Commerce, Mich. / Schoolcraft College | |
| Second Team | Azaad Liadi | So | F | Sterling Heights, Mich. / Henry Ford II HS |
| Michael Shaikly | Jr | MF | Colchester, England / University of Findlay | |
| Oakley Hanger | So | D | Weymouth, England / Southampton Solent | |
| Honorable Mention | Brian Sockow | Jr | D | Canton, Mich. |
| 2016 | ||||
| Defensive Player of the Year | Tyler Stephens | Sr. | Midfielder | Roseville, Mich. / Bishop Foley HS |
| Freshman of the Year | Roderic Green | Fr. | Midfielder | Commerce, Mich. / Lakeland HS |
| First-Team | Tyler Stephens | Sr. | Midfielder | Roseville, Mich. / Bishop Foley HS |
| Matt Wilson | Jr. | Forward | Huron Valley, Mich. / Huron Valley | |
| Troy Watson | Sr. | Midfield | Toronto, Ontario / Sir Wilfrid Laurier | |
| Andrew Dalou | So. | Midfield | West Bloomfield, Mich. / Walled Lake Central HS | |
| Second-Team | Roderic Green | Fr. | Midfielder | Commerce, Mich. / Lakeland HS |
| Liam Reilly | Fr. | Defender | Huddersfield, England | |
| Connor Keane | Fr. | Goalkeeper | Manchester, England / Loretta HS | |
| Honorable-Mention | Tobee Oyeleye | Sr. | Midfielder | London, England / West Virginia Tech |
| 2015 | ||||
| Offensive Player of the Year | Tyler Channell | Sr. | Forward | Troy, Mich. / Troy Athens |
| First-Team | Tyler Channell | Sr. | Forward | Troy, Mich. / Troy Athens |
| Jordan Kalk | Jr. | Forward | Richmond Hill, Ont. / Bill Crothers SS | |
| Troy Watson | Jr. | Midfielder | Toronto, Ont. / Sir Wilfrid Laurier | |
| Aleksandar Isaevski | So. | Defender | Skopje, Macedonia / John Glenn | |
| Second-Team | Tyler Stephens | Jr. | Midfielder | Roseville, Mich. / Bishop Foley |
| Vaughn Frederick | Sr. | Defender | Garden City, Mich. / Garden City | |
| Alex Bouillennec | So. | Goalkeeper | Pedernec, France / Lycee Notre Dame | |
| Honorable Mention | Omar Sinclair | Fr. | Defender | Manchester, England / Bury College |
| 2014 | ||||
| First-Team | Craig Neal | Sr. | Midfielder | Auburn, Mich. / Bay City Western |
| Zach Vasold | Sr. | Midfielder | Freeland, Mich. / Freeland | |
| Second-Team | Tyler Channell | Jr. | Forward | Troy, Mich. / Troy Athens |
| Honorable Mention | Alex Isaevski | Fr. | Midfielder | Skopje, Macadonia/Westland, Mich. / John Glenn |
| 2013 | ||||
| Offensive Player of the Year | Tyler Channell | So. | Forward | Troy, Mich. / Troy Athens |
| Defensive Player of the Year | Michael Lamb | Jr. | Defender | Sunderland, England/Oregon State Univ. |
| Freshman of the Year | Jordan Kalk | Fr. | Forward | Richmond Hill, Ont. / Bill Crothers |
| First-Team | Tyler Channell | So. | Forward | Troy, Mich. / Troy Athens |
| Lachlan Savage | Sr. | Midfielder | Canton, Mich. / Plymouth Salem | |
| Michael Lamb | Jr. | Defender | Sunderland, England/Oregon State Univ. | |
| Second-Team | Jordan Kalk | Fr. | Forward | Richmond Hill, Ont. / Bill Crothers |
| Zach Vasold | Jr. | Midfielder | Freeland, Mich. / Freeland | |
| Honorable Mention | Craig Neal | Jr. | Defender | Bay City, Mich. / Western |
| 2012 | ||||
| Offensive Player of the Year | Zach Myers | Sr. | Forward | Grand Rapids, Mich./Forest Hills Eastern |
| First-Team | Zach Myers | Sr. | Forward | Grand Rapids, Mich./Forest Hills Eastern |
| Jason Wise | Sr. | Goalkeeper | Troy, Mich./Troy HS | |
| Second-Team | Zach Walega | Jr. | Forward | Saline, Mich./Saline HS |
| Taylor Clarke | Jr. | Defender | Cary, Ill./Cary-Grove | |
| Michael Lamb | So. | Defender | Sunderland, England/Sandhill View | |
| Honorable Mention | Zach Vasold | So. | Midfielder | Freeland, Mich. / Freeland |
| 2011 | ||||
| Defensive Player of the Year | Zach Myers | Jr. | Defender | Grand Rapids, Mich./Forest Hills Eastern |
| Coach of the Year | Cale Wasserman | |||
| First-Team | Zach Walega | So. | Forward | Saline, Mich./Saline HS |
| Zach Myers | Jr. | Defender | Grand Rapids, Mich./Forest Hills Eastern | |
| Second-Team | Tyler Channell | Fr. | Forward | Troy, Mich. / Troy Athens |
| Lachlan Savage | So. | Midfielder | Canton, Mich. / Plymouth Salem | |
| Jason Wise | Jr. | Goalkeeper | Troy, Mich./Troy HS | |
| 2010 | ||||
| Second-Team | Noah Sawyer | Fr. | Forward | East Lansing, Mich./Haslett |
| Anthony Palazzolo | Sr. | Midfielder | Warren, Mich./De La Salle | |
| Zach Myers | So. | Defender | Grand Rapids, Mich./Forest Hills Eastern | |
| Piotr Kazmierczak | Sr. | Goalkeeper | Stargard, Poland/Kellogg CC | |
| 2009 | ||||
| First-Team | Kevin Fox | Sr. | Forward | Flushing, Mich./Flushing HS |
| Second-Team | Brock Humphries | Sr. | Defender | Shelby Township, Mich./Utica Eisenhower |
| 2007 | ||||
| First-Team | Jimmy Henry | Sr. | Forward | Oxford, Mich. |
| Kevin Fox | So. | Midfielder | Flushing, Mich./Flushing HS | |
| Second-Team | Brandon LeBlanc | Jr. | Midfielder | Saginaw, Mich./Heritage HS |
| Daniel Wragg | Jr. | Defender | Kirton Lindsey, England/Huntcliff | |
| 2005 | ||||
| First-Team | Cale Wassermann | Sr. | Midfielder | Southfield, Mich./Birmingham Groves |
| Second-Team | Jared Riepma | Sr. | Midfielder | Midland, Mich. |
| 2004 | ||||
| First-Team | Claudio Ciccetti | Sr. | Forward | Ancaster, Ont./St. Thomas Moore |
| Kyle Grant | Sr. | Forward | Milton, Ont./Bishop Reding | |
| Cale Wassermann | Jr. | Midfielder | Southfield, Mich./Birmingham Groves | |
| 2003 | ||||
| First-Team | Robert Alexander | So. | Forward | Midland, Mich. |
| Second-Team | Kyle Grant | Jr. | Forward | Milton, Ont./Bishop Reding |
| Adrian Thomas | Sr. | Goalkeeper | Marval, Trinidad & Tobago/Queens | |
| 2002 | ||||
| First-Team | Stephen Walker | So. | Midfielder | Manchester, England/Philips |
| Second-Team | Adrian Thomas | Jr. | Forward | Marval, Trinidad & Tobago/Queens |
| Paul Thomas | Jr. | Midfielder | Manchester, England/Kasken Moor | |
| 2001 | ||||
| First-Team | Grant Pierce | So. | Goalkeeper | Franklin, Tenn. |
| 2000 | ||||
| Second-Team | Boniface Anike | So. | Midfielder | Benin, Edo, Nigeria |