INDIVIDUAL RECORDS
SINGLE GAME
| Record | # | Individual | Date |
| Most Points | 49 | Michael Williams vs. Grand Valley | Feb. 19, 1994 |
| Most FG Made | 21 | Louis O'Neal vs. Lake Superior State | Jan. 29, 1981 |
| Most FG Attempts | 36 | Louis O'Neal vs. Siena Heights | Jan. 3, 1981 |
| Best FG Percentage | 100 | Bill Vitti vs. Alma {9/9} | Dec. 17, 1990 |
| 100 | Brandon Fisher vs. Oakland {9/9} | Jan. 30, 1995 | |
| 100 | Mike Zuiderveen vs. St. Joseph's {9/9} | Nov. 17, 2007 | |
| Most FT Made | 19 | Michael Williams vs. Ferris | Feb. 25, 1993 |
| Most FT Attempts | 25 | Michael Williams vs. St. Francis, IL | Nov. 27, 1993 |
| Best FT Percentage | 100 | Michael Williams vs. Hillsdale {13/13} | Jan. 30, 1993 |
| Most Consecutive FT | 13 | Norwaine Reed vs. Laurentien | Dec. 5, 1970 |
| 13 | Rod Creech vs. St. Mary's | Dec. 12, 1987 | |
| 13 | Rod Creech vs. Lake Superior State | Feb. 4, 1989 | |
| 13 | Michael Williams vs. Hillsdale | Jan. 30, 1993 | |
| Most 3-pt FG Made | 9 | Jake Daniels vs. Grace Bible College | Nov. 22, 2016 |
| Most 3-pt FG Attempts | 20 | Dante Williams vs. Ashland | Feb. 12, 2009 |
| Best 3-pt FG Percentage | 100 | Josh Ode vs. Oakland City, IN {6/6} | Nov. 19, 1997 |
| Most Rebounds | 22 | Michael Plowden vs. Spring Arbor | Nov. 28, 1979 |
| Most Assists | 16 | Art Harris vs. Lake Superior State | Feb. 10, 1973 |
| Most Steals | 9 | Charles Kelly vs. Oakland | Feb. 14, 1970 |
| 9 | Rod Creech vs. Aquinas | Dec. 7, 1988 |
SINGLE SEASON
| Record | # | Individual | Date |
| Most Points | 742 | Norwaine Reed (30) | 1971-72 |
| Best Scoring Average | 30.9 | Norwaine Reed | 1971-72 |
| Most FG Made | 299 | Norwaine Reed | 1971-72 |
| Most FG Attempts | 664 | Norwaine Reed | 1971-72 |
| Best FG Percentage | *64.2 | CJ Turnage {165-257} (22) | 2013-14 |
| Most FT Made | 152 | Tre Garrett | 2023-24 |
| Most FT Attempts | 197 | Tre Garrett | 2022-23 |
| Best FT Percentage | 91.1 | Brett Beland {72-79} | 2011-12 |
| Consecutive FT Made | 35 | Eli Redman {1-28 to 2-15} | 2011-12 |
| Most 3-point FG Made | 85 | Darnell Hoskins Jr. (28) | 2018-19 |
| Most 3-point FG Attempts | 228 | Darnell Hoskins Jr. (28) | 2018-19 |
| Best 3-point FG Percentage | 44.9 | Anthony Parker (26) | 2001-02 |
| Most Rebounds | 313 | Mike Zuiderveen (26) | 2007-08 |
| Best Rebound Average | 12.0 | Mike Zuiderveen {313/26} | 2007-08 |
| Most Assists | 185 | Kellen Smith (33) | 2015-16 |
| Most Steals | 81 | Spider Edwards (32) | 1982-83 |
* - Minimum 5 FG made per game & player much play in 75% of their team's games
Games Played in (parentheses)
CAREER
| Record | # | Individual | Date |
| Best Scoring Average | 27.8 | Norwaine Reed {1,645/59} | 1969-72 |
| Most FG Attempts | 2,070 | Louis O'Neal (116) | 1978-82 |
| Best FG Percentage | *61.0 | Bill Vitti {520/852} (112) | 1989-92 |
| Most FT Attempts | 612 | Norwaine Reed (59) | 1969-72 |
| Best FT Percentage | 86.2 | James Toohey (119-138) | 2017-22 |
| Most 3-point FG Made | 277 | Darnell Hoskins Jr. | 2017-22 |
| Most 3-point FG Attempts | 782 | Darnell Hoskins Jr. | 2017-22 |
| Best 3-point FG Percentage | 40.6 | Anthony Parker {176/434} | 2002-05 |
| Best Rebound Average | 9.3 | Bill Vitti {1,045/112 games} | 1989-92 |
* - Minimum four made per games played by team
Games Played in (parentheses)