2022

Nick Whiteside 

AFCA First Team All-America

2021

Nick Whiteside 

Associated Press NCAA DII All-American Second Team 

2016

Matt McKoy
AFCA All-American Second Team
AP Little All-American First Team  

2013

Jeff Janis
AFCA All-American First Team
Daktronics, Inc. All-American First Team
AP Little All-American First Team

2012

Jeff Janis
Daktronics, Inc. All-American First Team

2009

John Jacobs
AFCA All-American First Team
Daktronics, Inc. All-American Second Team

2008

John Jacobs
Daktronics, Inc. All-American Second Team

2005

John DiGiorgio
AFCA All-American First Team

2004

Todd Herremans
AFCA All-AmericanFirst Team
GLIAC Offensive "Lineman of the Year"

2000

Brian Dolph
AFCA All-American First Team

1998

Lamar King
AFCA All-American First Team

1997

Kent Kraatz
GLIAC Offensive "Lineman of the Year"

Paul Spicer
AFCA All-American First Team
GLIAC "Player of the Year"

1992

Bill Schafer
AFCA All-American First Team

1990

David Cook
AFCA All-American First Team

1989

Kevin Mitchell
Associated Press All-American Second Team

1985

Tony Jones
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention (Fullback)

1984

Dave Berkey
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention (Punter)

Bryan Krukowski
NAIA All-American Second Team (Tailback)

Joe Rice
AFCA/NAIA All-American First Team

1983

Joe Iaquaniello
NAIA All-American Second Team (Safety)

Rust Mandle
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention

1981

Eugene Marve
NAIA All-American First Team (Linebacker)

1980

Eugene Marve
NAIA All-American First Team (Defensive End)

Melvin Mathews
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention (Receiver)

1979

Bob Loftus
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention (Offensive Tackle)

Ken Tolfree
NAIA All-American First Team (Cornerback)

Steve Zott
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention (Quarterback)

1978

Donald Maxwell
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention  (Nose Guard)

John Waters
NAIA All-American Honorable Mention (Running Back)

1977

John Waters
NAIA All-American Second Team (Running Back)